Pose Your Question to Ellison and Fields
Patch wants to get you involved in the District 5 race.
So often, election seasons feature candidates repeating the same talking points over and over, and media members asking the same questions over and over.
Patch wants to switch things up a bit with this year's 5th Congressional District race.
We're asking you, the Patch user, to pose a question to incumbent Democratic Rep. Keith Ellison and/or Republican challenger Chris Fields.
To pose a question, simply post it as a comment below. Make sure to make it clear who the question is for (just Keith, just Chris or both candidates).
Patch editors will then use select questions during upcoming interviews with both candidates.
Joe Ross
9:51 am on Tuesday, July 24, 2012
It feels like the GOP have the democrats outgunned when it comes to PR. Do you feel like the GOP has played the game of politics better? I think the democratic voters would like to see the blame for our broken government placed loudly and more squarely on the leaders of the GOP. For example, the GOP led congress has voted more than 30 times to repeal Obamacare but not ONCE for a jobs bill? How is that not front page news for the Dems?
Michael Rose
9:53 am on Tuesday, July 24, 2012
Joe, who would you like that question to go to: just Keith, just Chris, or both candidates?
Dwight McCullough
8:08 am on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
I guess I could sort of answer that question Joe. Obamacare will add to our debt and taxes and many many more regulations. The problem is the regulations and taxes that choke off businesses who then don't dare or unable because of the lack of money they have to hire more people and jobs.... Government does NOT provide jobs, unless they are government jobs. You cannot continue to grow government without the money to fund it... Does that make sense to you?
Jack
12:32 pm on Tuesday, July 24, 2012
I just do not understand the mindset of Michelle Bachmann and Her Choir. She makes unfounded statements, no facts, no substance and totally thoughtless. Yet She still bamboozles Her rabid constituants into voting for this completely idiiotic tripe. Maybe we should ask about Her Brand of Tea ?.
Dwight McCullough
8:13 am on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
Jack, perhaps you have not heard the 'rest of the story' ? It isn't just congresswoman Bachmann, but several more asking these questions.... What is wrong with asking questions Jack?
Here is the letter. Will YOU take the time to read it?
http://www.scribd.com/doc/100225465/Michele-Bachmann-Letter-to-Keith-Ellison-2012-07-13
Eric
12:55 pm on Thursday, July 26, 2012
There is too much evidence against Ellison and the rest of the Islamists that their allegiance is to the Muslim Brotherhood and therefore that they are traitors to the United States. It is anathema that he is holding the position of congressman. For freedom he must be replaced with an American.
Eric
6:58 pm on Thursday, July 26, 2012
Dwight, thanks for posting the document. Those who care about America should read it.
Tea Mage
12:50 pm on Tuesday, July 24, 2012
Both candidates:
Do you feel that you..
1) own yourself, and
2) it's morally wrong to initiate force against another individual acting peacefully?
If either one of you answers yes to these questions, how could you support the Federal Reserve system in co-operation with the IRS putting people in a cage if they do not use the FRN's as currency in their right to exchange goods and services, as they currently do? (Bernard Von Nothause w/Liberty Dollar, etc)
Don Allen-IBNN
12:58 pm on Tuesday, July 24, 2012
Congressman Ellison and Candidate Fields: As you know, the Minneapolis Urban League should be a flagship organization in Minnesota. Two weeks ago, the MUL shutdown the south Minneapolis office. Last year they closed the group home and elementary school. To Keith: The DFL political plantation has strangled new leadership in the 5th CD with it's "prominent Negro" position versus doing the work. What will be your (Keith) advise to the Minneapolis Urban League? To Chris: The Minnesota GOP is a racist, antiquated and just plan "back-assward" political organization in Minnesota. If you beat Keith, what will you do different to develop and peaceful middle-ground between emotional liberals and uninformed Republicans?
Dwight McCullough
6:56 am on Thursday, July 26, 2012
Don Allen-IBNN, As a member of MN-GOP, you may be assured that we are NOT racist, no matter how many times it has been said, does NOT make it true. [Hitler said if you say it over and over, it becomes truth, quote] There is ONE race, the 'human' one... Yes, I agree, conservatives are polar opposites. Now would you take the time to understand that what we value are the founders principles. [i.e. the declaration of independence/the constitution ]Which the modern 'democratic party' is trying to destroy... JFK and Truman are rolling over in their graves... I have been a member of the DFL, a union steward and organizer and I understand what this party was. It NO LONGER is my friend....
Nick Leyendecker
1:06 pm on Tuesday, July 24, 2012
To Keith Ellison. Why don't you support HR 459, Audit the Fed bill? The Fed is a private bank with public privileges and a creature of congress. Congress is responsible for keeping the Fed in check. The lower/moderate income citizens of Mpls are among those who are hurt the worst by inflation and the Fed's monetary policies. The elderly of Mpls are unable to grow their money safely in savings because rates are so low. Only the wealthiest corporations are able to borrow money from the Fed at 0% while the middle class gets the shaft. How do you plan to represent the middle class and promote sound money?
Karen M
1:06 pm on Tuesday, July 24, 2012
Both:
Is it truly the job of the Federal Government to "create jobs" across the country? If so, how can they do it without taking money that would be spent (aka 'stimulus' to the economy) in the private sector and pushing that same money through the public sector? If no, then what decisions can Congress make that would allow job growth in the private sector?
Spirit Medicine
1:12 pm on Tuesday, July 24, 2012
There are some who are concerned with the continual growth in the powers claimed by the executive branch of the United States, expansions of authority not isolated to the current administration.
This question is for both candidates.
What, if anything, are some things that the executive branch under the U.S. Constitution should never be allowed to do?
Troy Henry
1:47 pm on Tuesday, July 24, 2012
To both! It's no wonder sanctions don't stop Iran from being shielded from Russia and China. How or what would you do, if given the op to make this president or the UN answer?
Ryan Laniel
2:33 pm on Tuesday, July 24, 2012
Do you know what certain incomes of persons and activities that have been imposed upon in the tax code?
What is the privilege to be excised in private sector domestic wages?
Do you know the deception we are subjected to from the government when asked on forms, Are you a U.S. citizen?
Ryan Laniel
2:48 pm on Tuesday, July 24, 2012
to both.
Jim Steele
3:49 pm on Tuesday, July 24, 2012
To Keith- Why did you lie about being on the Foreign Affairs Committee when you were on Al McFarlane's radio show in May?
Tom Johnson
5:00 pm on Tuesday, July 24, 2012
To both candidates - Minneapolis has the highest racial unemployment gap in the country. Is that because of individual's choices or the governments?
Loren Piller
7:23 am on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
Keith, will you give an accounting of your relationships with various Islamic groups and tell us why you think Rep. Bachman is wrong in her allegations against you?
Grant Vlasak
7:31 am on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
This is for Congressman Ellison: Please tell us; what were your reasons for voting 'no' on the NDAA?
For both Congressman Ellison and Mr. Fields: Would you work to repeal it? If so, how, and when?
For reference: On December 31, 2011, President Obama signed the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), codifying indefinite military detention without charge or trial into law for the first time in American history. The NDAA’s detention provisions would authorize the president — and all future presidents — to order the military to pick up and indefinitely imprison people captured anywhere in the world, far from any battlefield.
Habeas corpus is a writ (legal action) which requires a person under arrest to be brought before a judge or into court. This ensures that a prisoner can be released from unlawful detention, in other words, detention lacking sufficient cause or evidence. It has historically been an important legal instrument safeguarding individual freedom against arbitrary state action. The U.S. Constitution specifically includes the habeas corpus procedure in the Suspension Clause (Clause 2), located in Article One, Section 9. This states that "The privilege of the writ of habeas corpus shall not be suspended, unless when in cases of rebellion or invasion, the public safety may require it." Former Presidents Abraham Lincoln, Ulysses Grant, and George W. Bush have all signed the suspension of Habeas Corpus.
Todd Johnson
10:31 am on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
Keith & Chris, Whoever wins this race will be my representative during the 100th anniversary of the American income tax. Do you believe the government should take more or less of my earnings?
Lemmen Kainen
11:53 am on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
To both candidates: It is obvious to almost everyone that the faltering economy is hurting Minnesota families. Predatory lending and criminal fraudclosures by banks have forced people from their homes, and often the current bankruptcy laws prevent people from moving forward. Do you have any plans to remove the restrictions implemented by the Bankruptcy Reform Act of 2005 and also to allow student loans to once again be dischargeable in a bankruptcy?
Will Bildsten
8:31 am on Thursday, July 26, 2012
Relieving people of debts they agreed to is against American values of personal responsibility and fairness. When an individual takes out a loan, it is his or her responsibility to pay it. Theft is theft, no matter how much money the person/company being stolen from has. If people are not going to follow the rules concerning bankruptcy and debt, they shouldn't get loans.
Mitch Mueller
2:25 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
To both candidates -
The last several years have witnessed a gradual erosion of religious freedom. Firstly, many religiously motivates charities are losing contracts to provide all kinds of services to the poor because their religious beliefs conflict with government dogma. Secondly, the Obama administration unlaterally decided that it did not like the Defence of Marriage Act passed under Bill Clinton, and will therefore pretend that this law does not exist. Thirdly, a Christian man in Massachusets was arrested forprotesting the teaching of homosexuality to his kindergarten son in public school without parental consent or permission. What will you do to protect our first ammendment right to religion and religious expression.
Will Bildsten
8:28 am on Thursday, July 26, 2012
Mitch, I agree that religious expression is a right. However, I don't think it is a teacher's place to be political. Teachers should always be apolitical, no matter what.
Also, it is not against religious expression to repeal DOMA. Many Americans support DOMA, while many others do not. Many view it as a social issue not related to religion. Federal marriage policy has nothing to do with religious expression.
John J Cain
3:39 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
TO Congressman Ellison:
Do you or do you not support the integration of Sharia Law into the laws of the United States?
John J Cain
3:52 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
Is there a reason for deleting my comment? John J Cain
Mitch Mueller
4:02 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
John, I see what you are doing and it is not only incredibly disingenuous, but wrong-headed. I am talking about religious freedom, not making religious doctorines the law. There is a huge difference between a persons right to have health insurance that jives with their religious beliefs, and that person making those beliefs the law of the land. I am concerned about the former and not the latter. Or don't you believe that the first ammendment means anything? Trolling comments like these have no place in an arena where serious questions are being posed to political candidates. Your question is obviously not a serious one because there is absolutely no precedence for it. I give the precendence for my question - you have given none for yours. Added to this precendence - Mayor bloomberg of New york has expressed that it is his goal that he make practicing abortions necessary for a person to recieve a license to practice medicine. It is one thing to be pro-choice, it's a completely different thing to say that ALL DOCTORS MUST FALL IN LINE - OR ELSE...
DaveW
4:12 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
To Keith Ellison:
Why did you vote "nay" on HR 459, "Audit the Fed" - especially given that other recent efforts at mandatory disclosure with regard to the Federal Reserve Bank resulted in the exposure of trillions of dollars of bailouts to foreign banks that US citizens would otherwise have known nothing about.
To Chris:
How would you have voted on Audit the Fed, and why?
Will Bildsten
8:23 am on Thursday, July 26, 2012
Keith's progressive intentions are not the problem; the problem is he is unwilling to pay for them and demand fiscal responsibility among government agencies. The fact that he didn't audit the fed proves he has little concern over the national debt. I have a liberal cousin who believes money isn't real, which is his justification for un-controlled government spending.
John J Cain
4:34 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
OHKAAAY! My comment is strictly for the Congressman. His answer would determine my vote. I spent 20 years of my life defending the First Amendment and all the rest of them. You are entitled to your opinions and your precedence as am I. There is more to Sharia than just health care which,by the way, is not a Right.
Gwen Nawrocki
7:39 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
This question is for Keith Ellison.
When you were a candidate for Congressman, it came out in the media that you had Numerous Unpaid Parking tickets. Have they ever been paid? At the time you said that your manager would take care of that. I understand that your wife was your manager at that time.
Gwen Nawrocki
Robert Hemphill
8:30 pm on Wednesday, July 25, 2012
What specific choices would you make (who would you raise taxes on, what programs would you cut) in order to balance the budget?
michael formanek
6:14 am on Thursday, July 26, 2012
to Keith Ellison Explain your recent vote of no on the Audit the Fed Bill. Many of us from all political leanings would like to know what deals have been made by the Federal Reserve.
Dwight McCullough
6:58 am on Thursday, July 26, 2012
Do you know what HR25 'The Fair Tax' is? And do you support it?
Will Bildsten
8:21 am on Thursday, July 26, 2012
One of the most defining issues of our day is our growing national debt. Under President Obama and the Democratic legislature from 2009-2010, the US was running deficits significantly higher than $1 trillion, or 1/15 of our economy.
As a 17-year-old moderate, I would like to know what your plan (both Keith and Chris) is to reduce deficits and put America on a path to paying down our unsustainable debt. I don't want to have to pay for baby boomers' retirements, when the 65-year retirement age was coined in the 1800s when people often didn't live that long. Would you support cutting spending, raising revenue, or a combination? If so, what programs would you cut and/or which taxes would you raise?
Eric
12:49 pm on Thursday, July 26, 2012
Question For Ellison: Since Muslims call for the destruction of the United States and replacement of the Constitution with sharia law, how have you been doing your part as a Muslim to accomplish these goals?
Donna Moss
12:55 pm on Thursday, July 26, 2012
For both candidates: Congress recently voted to keep the interest rates of federal subsidized Stafford loans frozen at 3.4% for the next year--at which point rates will return to their original 6.8% unless further action is taken. Congressman Ellison, you've frequently emphasized the importance of making higher education more affordable. What is your next step? Mr. Fields, given your professed interest in "improving the quality of education at all levels," (as your website states) and in narrowing the achievement gap, how would you propose to make higher education more accessible to middle- and lower-class students?
Lauren
1:04 pm on Thursday, July 26, 2012
To Both: Do you plan to vote yes or no on the voter ID amendment? Why or why not? How do you feel about the fact that 70% of students at the U of M Twin Cities alone would be impacted by this amendment?
Seth Engman
1:21 pm on Thursday, July 26, 2012
To both - is it ever appropriate to characterize your opponent or those that disagree with you as "anti-american" ?
Eric
1:30 pm on Thursday, July 26, 2012
If they are, yes it is. "anti-" means against, and "American" here refers to a set of moral values, political principles, and cultural norms. In the case of Ellison, it is a duty to call him and his ilk what they are, which is anti-American. This election is about a choice, America or the dark vision of oppression and slavery that Ellison's office portends.
Mike Thompson
5:13 pm on Thursday, July 26, 2012
I second Seth's question.
Eric, did your mommy let you on the computer today? Because you did a really awesome job explaining to everyone what the word "anti" and "American" meant.
Why don't you take your tin foil hat off and come to realize the sky isn't going to fall and nuclear war isn't going to start because Keith Ellison is in congress. And no, people are not going to become "slaves" because of Ellison. This has to be one of the sorriest comments I have ever read on any webpage, pure scare tactics and utter nonsense.
Eric
5:34 pm on Thursday, July 26, 2012
Mike Thompson,
Every man is responsible for what he does and chooses not to do, for what he says and chooses not to say, and all the consequences that he could forsee from those choices.
Mike Thompson
7:00 pm on Thursday, July 26, 2012
Eric, I know that choices have consequences, but please explain to everyone how Keith Ellison is anti-American and how he is oppressive and leading Americans into slavery? These are quite serious charges, and unless you have something to back them up with, then I would seriously encourage you to quit the Bachmannesque crazy talk.
Eric
7:16 pm on Thursday, July 26, 2012
Mike Thompson:
Start at the beginning: Does Islam, and hence do Muslims, entail oppression, murder, slavery (dhimmitude), humiliation, and bigotry?
Mike Thompson
9:58 pm on Thursday, July 26, 2012
No Eric, Islam is a peaceful religion. There are extremists in every religion that do silly and violent things, and I don't support any of them. As you should be aware, the First Amendment of the Constitution safeguards religious freedoms. Which like it or not, some American's are Muslims.
Also, how did Lynne Torgerson's anti-Muslim strategy workout for her last time?
What else do you have?
Eric
12:20 am on Friday, July 27, 2012
Mike Thompson: Good. You have revealed your ostensible premise, which is most dreadfully incorrect, and from which all of your nonsense derives.
Mike Thompson
10:10 am on Friday, July 27, 2012
Eric, you're a very sick person. A man once defined hell as a place where there is no reason, and you just dragged me into hell.
Abigail Smith
2:36 pm on Thursday, July 26, 2012
To both: What are your thoughts on the approaching "fiscal cliff" in January, when current temporary tax cuts are set to expire? Would you support a bill that would allow tax breaks for the wealthiest 2% of Americans (those making $250,000 a year or more) to expire while preserving tax cuts for the middle class?
Chris Steller
10:43 am on Friday, July 27, 2012
I deleted a comment by "chrisf" that was also signed "Chris Fields" Under Patch's Terms of Use (http://fridley.patch.com/terms), Patch encourages but does not require that the user name you provide be your real name. Still, users agree not to post content that "is inaccurate, false or misleading in any way." Don't post under someone else's name.
Christian U
11:44 am on Saturday, July 28, 2012
This question is for both Chris Fields and Congressman Keith Ellison. We are voting on two important Constitutional amendments, can you tell us how you plan to vote and why you are voting that way on the issue of the Marriage and the Voter ID Amendments?
Stevenrt
12:01 pm on Saturday, July 28, 2012
The congressional budget office announced not to long ago the affordable care act actually cuts the deficit, and repeal would be costly and contribute to the deficit, what is Mr. Fields response to these findings? Why don't we strengthen the act rather then just wipe it way, it is at less a start, correct?
Aaron Rosenthal
12:55 pm on Saturday, July 28, 2012
A question for both candidates: what are your feelings about the budget proposed by Congressman Paul Ryan?
Kevin Parks
1:32 pm on Saturday, July 28, 2012
To Rep. Fields,
It has been reported that after the Colorado shooting, you may propose that a limit be put on ammunition purchased over the internest, as well as that protective (AKA Kevlar) style clothing should only be in possesion of Law enforcement or military. My question is, why do you believe defensive style body armor should not be held by anyone other than those parties, and why now and not months ago?
Kevin Parks
1:34 pm on Saturday, July 28, 2012
I apologize, the above question was for Rep. Ellison and not for Mr. Fields.
Eric Ferguson
1:12 am on Monday, July 30, 2012
Question for both: what can we do to help the participants in the Arab Spring protests?
Ezra Pound
8:45 pm on Thursday, August 2, 2012
Chris Fields you mentioned on your WCCO interview that if elected to Congress you would support any good idea regardless from what party introduced it or supported it. Do you see yourself as a follower who only supports others's ideas or do you see yourself as a leader who creates the ideas and other follows? Assuming you choose the latter, then I would like to hear your idea(s) and how you would get support from either party.
Congressmen Keith Ellison how did you respond to Chris Fields' request to join him for a sandwich, during Ramadan, at Chick-Fil-A?
Eric
10:39 am on Friday, August 3, 2012
Ellison is a Muslim Brotherhood supporter, like all Muslims. The Muslim Brotherhood is the ideological origin of all Islamic groups, including Al Qaeda, Boko Haram, The Muslim SS that operated in the Balkans in WW II, Abu Sayaf, Hamas, etc. The Muslim Brotherhood's aim in the USA is to destroy our government by infiltration by Muslims like Ellison; apply a mixture of physical intimidation, political pressure, lawfare, and propaganda to impose Sharia law. Sharia law is the system of Muslim enslavement, oppression, and murder of non-Muslims. It is a Muslim supremacist system in which non-Muslims are inferior and subject to physical violence and death for violating its strictures. This, conquest and subjugation of non-Muslims, is the basis of the Muslims' belief system and the guide of their actions. Defeat the Muslim Ellison.
Chris Steller
11:32 am on Friday, August 3, 2012
Eric (plain Eric, not Eric Ferguson): You lost me at "like all Muslims." In Jan. 2011, the Pew Research Center estimated there were 1.6 billion Muslims worldwide. A glance at the news suggests they don't all agree on who to support.
Jesse Lykken
2:20 pm on Monday, August 6, 2012
To Rep. Ellison: Why have you not helped organize an anti-war march in Minneapolis? Your supporters say that there is little you can get done legislatively as a rookie, but it seems to me that you have not made very good use of your Bully Pulpit. Please don't bring up some little items to prove me wrong. Please show us how you have shouted from the Capital dome day after day that war is wrong.
RP45241
9:32 am on Thursday, August 30, 2012
Mr. Ellison,
How can you truly believe and look in the face of the Minnesota people and tell them that the last 4 years have been great for the middle class? By raising taxes of the rich, you are not going to add any thing for the middle class...You are just curbing their progress. This is not a zero-sum game here !!!